Transgender: Some answers from the Catholic Perspective | Santhosh Kumar Appu

 Historical facts:

A little bit of Church history will tell us that the rules were not created first. Instead, people started to live out what they believed: that Jesus Christ was a savior who had risen from the dead. During those early years of the Church's growth, a person's gender identity did not matter; the human person mattered.

  1. A gender-nonconforming individual is the reason the good news was brought to Ethiopia. The Acts of the Apostles records this fact. A court official, who was a eunuch, was returning from Jerusalem after worshiping there. The Bible states: “And the Spirit said to Philip, ‘Go over and join this chariot.’” Philip went and sat with him. After their conversation, they stopped at a body of water, and the eunuch was baptized. Therefore, because the Spirit commanded it, the eunuch was baptized. It is certain that God’s grace is available to all and excludes no one.
  2. The second historical fact is quite interesting. It comes from the 4th-century life of St. John Chrysostom. He was living in Antioch as a zealous priest. He was brought to Constantinople by a eunuch named Eutropius, the highest official in the imperial court. Is it not surprising that God made a priest into a bishop with the aid of a eunuch?



Current Theological Position

God created everything and found it all good. All things are naturally ordered toward the good. A tree is ordered toward providing fruit. Water is ordered toward quenching thirst and cleansing. Similarly, when God created humans, He ordered them to grow and multiply. Procreation is part of this order. Thus, it is argued that a transgender person cannot procreate. Morally speaking, when a biological male decides to go against nature and live as a woman, this is a moral decision that goes against the good for which God created them. Therefore, the Church does not accept this decision or moral act, and rejects it.

However, prior to that moral act, there is a human person. In the words of the Church, that transgender person may lose their moral dignity, but not their ontological dignity—their God-given dignity. One can read about this in the declaration on human dignity by the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, titled Dignitas Infinita.

As a follow-up to this understanding of the infinite dignity of the human person, another declaration was released regarding blessings. This was also issued by the same dicastery and is titled Fiducia Supplicans. Here, it speaks about blessings. The simple argument is that if God wants to bless a third-gender or transgender person, who are humans to block it? It is not an official blessing of an irregular or same-sex union using regular liturgical rites. Rather, it is about genuine pastoral care. If a transgender person comes and asks, "Father, bless me," then that priest is obliged to give it.

Regarding the reception of other sacraments, the dicastery says: “A transgender person—even after undergoing hormone treatment and sex-reassignment surgery—can receive Baptism under the same conditions as other believers, if there are no situations in which there is a risk of generating public scandal or disorientation among the faithful” (https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_ddf_20231031-documento-mons-negri_en.html).

Conscience the most secret sanctuary

“His conscience is man's most secret core and his sanctuary. There he is alone with God whose voice echoes in his depths” (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1776). Here, no one can enter. No one can poke their nose in; even the Pope cannot enter and dictate anything, said the Doctor of the Church, Cardinal Newman. If so, then let the transgender person speak to God and decide.

Dorothy and agenda push

Left and right ideologies need deep discussion. Because the Church stands by the poor and the afflicted, it is naturally leftist in many ways.

Last words

Regarding a question on the removal of genitals, a transgender person told me, “It was annoying me; I felt it was unnecessary because my whole inner feelings and desires were the exact opposite of it.”

Transgender people have been part of history. They are human, so they have undeniable dignity, and there is nothing preventing them from receiving the sacraments. In their conscience, and in their conversation with God, they decide to do what they do—who are we to judge? Their inner urges and bodily desires cannot be discarded.

கருத்துரையிடுக

0 கருத்துகள்